home » blog »

Insights from Brazilian endocrinologist — don’t forget your D

Last week I had the pleasure of meeting the Brazilian endocrinologist and vitamin D researcher Dr. Marise Lazaretti Castro at a meeting of bone researchers held at the National Institutes of Health (NIH) in Bethesda, MD. Like many other open-minded physicians, Dr. Lazaretti and colleagues became fascinated with the new research on the wide-ranging benefits of vitamin D and they wanted to learn more about vitamin D levels in their hometown, São Paulo, Brazil (latitude 23°S). The result was a year-long, 591-person study on vitamin D.

Vitamin D levels of study participants (measured in ng/mL)

Group Winter Summer
Nursing 14.4 16.8
Community 17.6 23.6
Active Elderly 31.2 36.4
Young >27.6 >41.2

The participants were divided into four groups: elderly living in nursing homes (Nursing), elderly living in the community (Community), elderly enrolled in an outdoor physical activity program (Active Elderly), and a group of young people around the age of 23 years (Young). Their vitamin D levels were tested throughout the year, and Dr. Lazaretti and her colleagues found some interesting results.

One of the first and most important findings is that the 20 ng/mL level of vitamin D proposed by the US Institute of Medicine for adequate bone protection is actually 10 ng/mL too low. Based on control and optimization of parathyroid hormone levels, Lazaretti found that vitamin D levels should be above 30 ng/mL for bone protection.

She also found the following:

  • Overall, the elderly had deficient vitamin D levels throughout the year, with nursing home residents having the lowest levels.
  • The active elderly enrolled in an outdoor exercise program maintained minimal vitamin D adequacy throughout the year. Interestingly, the outdoor active elderly were able to produce as much vitamin D from sun exposure as did the young group. This finding is in contrast to the popular notion that older individuals produce less vitamin D upon sunlight exposure than do younger individuals.
  • In the winter, the outdoor exercising elderly were the only group able to maintain vitamin D adequacy. Even the young group fell below 30 ng/mL level during the winter.
  • There was a 3-month delay between the time of lowest ultraviolet radiation and the time of lowest vitamin D blood levels. The vitamin D blood levels fell to their lowest in October, while the lowest UV radiation occurred three months earlier in June.


Better Bones take home messages

Dr. Lazaretti’s research reminds us of the importance of vitamin D and its connection to Better Bones. Here’s a quick start to healthier bones:

1. Get your vitamin D level tested.
2. Protect your skeleton with at least a 30 ng/mL level. Our target vitamin D level is 50 ng throughout the year.
3. Supplement with vitamin D as necessary. Each 1,000 IU of vitamin D3 generally raises the vitamin D level 10 ng/mL.
4. Exercise outdoors and enjoy the sunlight when possible.

Reference:
Maeda, S et al. 2011. 25-hydroxyvitamin D delayed response to seasonal ultraviolet radiation type B: The São Paulo vitamin D evaluation study (SPADES). Poster #P29, Forum on Aging and Skeletal Health, ASBMR, March 21-22, held at the NIH, Bethesda, MD.

We created the Osteo Blast blog as our forum to express opinions and educate the public about natural means of supporting and improving bone health and overall wellness. As part of this forum, we sometimes discuss medical issues and medications, and their effects on bone health in general. However, we cannot advise readers about specific medical issues in this forum. If you wish to obtain advice from Susan E. Brown, PhD, about your specific bone health and nutritional concerns, please visit our Consultations page. Other specific medical questions should be referred to your healthcare provider.

 

Comments

April 23. 2011 02:56

I wanted to know the effect of hormons for building our bones. I used take hormon therapy when I was having difficulty in menopouse but learned about the side effects of using hormon then stop taking it. Is there any way to use hormons for our bones without having problems. I heard that if you take appropriate doses of sertain hormons will help bone dansity and also keep your youth.

mariko partrick

April 25. 2011 09:53

Dear Mariko,
Any time you take ANY drug (and hormone therapies qualify) there is a risk of unintended effects, both good AND bad, so there's no easy answer to your question. Plenty of women use hormone therapy without any problems, but others experience side effects and complications. The decision to use hormone therapies for menopause, for bone health, or for any other purpose is one that must be made based on individual health circumstances. Some women do well on them, others don't -- it's really that simple. The jury is still out on the long-term effects of hormones used for anti-aging, but given that we tend to favor a natural approach that uses the body's existing healing capacity in the presence of good food, appropriate nutrition, exercise, and emotional wellness, it's not an approach that we at Better Bones are likely to promote.

Managing Editor

May 31. 2011 20:37

Wish that I could exercise outdoors more. But this is the Chicago area - rain, thunderstorms, gloom, and not that many sunny outdoor days. Exercising outdoors is also seasonal, and only if there are no thunderstorms or rainstorms.

Vicki Jones

June 1. 2011 08:47

As a native Chicagoan now living in Maine, I personally understand JUST what you mean! And given that this study took place in Brazil, they had another advantage that we northerners don't have -- the sun supplies vitamin D even in winter (not the case in either Chicago or Maine). In our case, it's necessary to use supplements to make up for the lack of sunshine. Fortunately, vitamin D is inexpensive and easy to get. A place to exercise away from the elements is a little more difficult to obtain, if climbing over snowplow mounds isn't your idea of fun exercise. That's one reason we offer exercise alternatives in the form of videos and the OsteoBall in our Shop section.

Best of luck!

Managing Editor

June 1. 2011 13:24

Hi,
I was wondering if in their studies or in yours there is an amount of overdose in Vitamin D?  
Can you discuss this issue a bit...as I am hearing many people are taking too much in the way of supplementation in the Vit D category.

thank you,
dr.p~

dr. patryce a

June 2. 2011 13:20

Dr. Patryce,
Although vitamin D toxicity is uncommon, it can occur and with it you see high calcium levels.  U.S. agencies have recently suggested that 4000 IU is safe for the average healthy individual. Some people may need less than this and some may be more to obtain an adequate blood level of vitamin D. Here at the Center for Better Bones we like to see a 50 ng level all year around, and we always like to see individuals who are using vitamin D be tested for their vitamin D blood levels once in the summer and once in the winter. There is a great deal of information on vitamin D, it safety and its toxicity, on the Internet; you might check into The Vitamin D Council and grassrootshealth.net
best wishes, Susan Brown

Susan Brown

Add comment





Loading




Recent Posts