home » blog »
Print Bookmark Size small medium large

Can prunes reverse bone loss?

My friend and fellow osteoporosis researcher Dr. Bahram Arjmandi says yes, the humble prune can reverse bone loss, and his research data is looking strong. For more than a decade Dr. Arjmandi of Florida State University in Tallahassee has tested a wide variety of “functional foods” for their potential impact on bone health. He has studied soy, blueberries, strawberries, raisins, dates, and finally prunes. No other natural substance, he reports, comes near to having the bone-building effect of prunes. Further, when I saw him at the ASBMR international bone meeting last fall, he reported he had never seen any natural substance produce such consistent beneficial bone-building results.

Dr. Arjmandi’s several successful animal and human studies document that special phenolic compounds in dried plums up-regulate growth factors linked to bone formation (such as IGF-1) and counter the activity of factors that inhibit bone formation (such as TNF-alpha). It probably also helps that prunes are one of the foods highest in antioxidants and also contain generous amounts of various key bone nutrients including potassium, boron, and copper. While Dr. Arjmandi has found other natural substances capable of halting bone loss, prunes were the only food found to actually restore lost bone.

This summer Dr. Arjmandi and colleagues will complete a landmark, controlled human clinical trial on prunes and bone health. For this study, 120 post-menopausal women have been taking either 100 grams of prunes (9-10 a day) or an equivalent portion of dried apples for one year. While it will be a few more months before all the research data is in, thus far 30 women in the prune group have had at least a 6% increase in hip bone, and one woman had an exceptional 11% increase consuming prunes over the year. Preliminary data from a segment of research subjects found that all prune-eaters showed at least some improvement in bone mass by six months into the study. [update on this study can be found here]

For several years I have heard Dr. Arjmandi speak of his prune research and read many of his research articles. It makes sense: if you could limit factors that hinder bone formation, such as inflammation and oxidative stress, and at the same time up-regulate new bone formation growth factors, and provide key bone nutrients, you could well accomplish the unthinkable and stimulate new bone formation with a simple, wholesome food substance.

At the Center for Better Bones, a group of us (including myself) are doing our own “prune experiment.” If you are inclined to join us, take Dr. Arjmandi’s advice and start slowly with a few prunes a day, working up to the full 9-10 over time. I have found soaked or stewed prunes are easier to digest, and Dr. Arjmandi has found that prunes do not lead to either weight gain or increased blood sugar levels. Also they should help build new bone in men as well as women.

References:

Arjmandi, BH et al. 2002. Dried plums improve indices of bone formation in postmenopausal women. Journal of Women’s Health & Gender-Based Medicine, 11:61-68.

Hooshmand, S and Arjmandi, BH. 2009. Viewpoint: Dried plum, an emerging functional food that may effectively improve bone health. Ageing Res Rev, Apr 8:122-7.

 

 

We created the Osteo Blast blog as our forum to express opinions and educate the public about natural means of supporting and improving bone health and overall wellness. As part of this forum, we sometimes discuss medical issues and medications, and their effects on bone health in general. However, we cannot advise readers about specific medical issues in this forum. If you wish to obtain advice from Susan E. Brown, PhD, about your specific bone health and nutritional concerns, please visit our Consultations page. Other specific medical questions should be referred to your healthcare provider.

Comments

July 17. 2009 16:13

I've been doing this now for a few weeks - can't say for sure what's going on with my bones but I've seen benefits for my gut that's for certain! thanks!

Fenbeast

July 22. 2009 15:18

Fenbeast--glads to hear this, also you might note that prunes help reduce the craving for sweets and increase feeling of fullness and satisfaction.

Dr. Susan Brown

July 31. 2009 09:54

wow, that's true - sugar is one of my big problems and if I keep the prunes around so that I can eat them when I have a sugar craving, I've found I eat less sugar. I'm trying to quit sugar altogether now, and the prunes really are helping that effort.

Fenbeast

July 31. 2009 22:25

I was excited when I heard about this a month ago and have been eating 9 prunes each day with no adverse digestive effects. It has actually improved my digestion, probably because it counteracts the binding effects of calcium supplements that I take. Am looking forward to my next bone density test, as the last one indicated a drop of 2 points. Am also taking Fosteum, which my doctor recommended. Now I'll also focus on alkalizing. I'm 75 and walk briskly a couple of miles 3 or 4 times a week, bike 5 to 10 miles 3 or 4 x weekly, and do yoga/stretching each morning. Wish me "luck".

jane

September 10. 2009 15:43

It does make some since that prunes would help with bone health by reducing inflammation and maybe reducing free radicals that could potentially harm your bones, but I am sceptical that prunes would help build new bone mass. I look forward to seeing how this study turns out.

Hsa

October 6. 2009 20:50

Prunes are acidic which concerns me as an acidic diet causes boneloss.  I know we need some acid. I have been eating 10 prunes at night after a salad and I'm now wondering if I'm undoing the good of having a salad before consuming the prunes.

Any comments?

Virginia

October 6. 2009 20:57

Dr Susan, Can the fact that prunes are acidic cause problems with the PH balance of the body?

Virginia

October 16. 2009 13:59

Virginia and others,

Yes, prunes do have an acid-forming effect, as do many other wholesome foods. If we consume enough of the wholesome alkalizing foods then we don't have to worry about the impact of prunes on pH. It's always good to check out your own pH level using our procedure as detailed in our pH test.  For our information on pH testing see: kithttp://www.betterbones.com/store/default.aspx#testkits

Susan Brown

Susan Brown

February 10. 2010 03:19

When I was a child my grandmother suggested prunes to help with constipation and it worked! has anyone found that by eating so many prunes that it causes to much of a bowel movement?

Jeannie Jones

Add comment





Loading



Recent Posts