Rethinking “primary” osteoporosis: Isn’t all osteoporosis really just “secondary” osteoporosis?
The medical literature defines osteoporosis as either primary or secondary. Primary osteoporosis is held to be a bone disorder of relatively unknown origin that occurs with aging and accelerates at menopause. Authorities state that there is no direct or singular cause for primary osteoporosis.
Secondary osteoporosis, on the other hand, is the type of osteoporosis that has a direct cause. This type of osteoporosis is “secondary to,” or caused by, something else. For example, osteoporosis caused by the use of prednisone is a very common form of secondary osteoporosis.
Is there really such a thing as “primary osteoporosis”?
In many years of researching bone health, however, we at the Center for Better Bones have come to challenge this distinction between primary and secondary osteoporosis. Our work leads us to suggest that all osteoporosis is indeed caused by something, and in this sense, all osteoporosis is secondary osteoporosis. For example, the American College of Rheumatology has estimated that 20% of all osteoporosis in the US is due to use of steroid medications. Other researchers have suggested that 20% of all hip fractures are related to smoking. The use of acid-blocking drugs has been shown to double fracture rates. Some studies suggest that almost 20% of those with osteoporosis have the disorder caused or worsened by an excessive loss of calcium in the urine. Vitamin D inadequacy could be causing half or more of all osteoporosis, and so forth.
In other words, the more we scratch the surface, the more we see that many of our current dietary and lifestyle behaviors directly limit bone health and encourage osteoporosis. Even the classic primary osteoporosis that is vaguely attributed to “aging” is now known to be caused by many concrete factors that affect older people, such as reduced kidney function, vitamin D deficiency, chronic low-grade metabolic acidosis, increased use of mood-altering drugs and other pharmacological agents, reduced nutrient intake, loss of muscle mass, and a reduction in physical activity.
It is also interesting to note that when osteoporosis is discovered in men, a great effort is generally made to uncover the causes of this osteoporosis. In fact, most male osteoporosis is considered to have a secondary cause. When women are found to have osteoporosis, however, there are fewer attempts to discover the causes of this bone weakening and more a tendency to explain that this is just “primary osteoporosis,” something that happens to women as they go through menopause into their senior years — as if it were normal to the female gender. But in other cultures, women don’t develop osteoporosis as a matter of course — and that says it’s not normal.
We at the Center for Better Bones, however, suggest that if you look carefully enough you will find secondary causes for almost all the osteoporosis among women just as in men. If we can’t find the cause, it is because our tools are not yet precise enough to catch the problem, not because there is no cause.
Below I list the disorders and conditions associated with the development of osteoporosis. These are recognized causes of “secondary osteoporosis.” Over time, I suspect you will see this list grow as we come to understand that all osteoporosis has a cause and is indeed secondary to something else.
Known secondary causes of osteoporosis
Table 1. Nutritional Factors
|Nutrition||Anti-nutrients||Modern eating patterns|
|Chronic low-grade metabolic acidosis||High caffeine intake||High fat intake|
|Imbalance among the 20 key bone nutrients||High salt intake||High sugar intake|
|Inadequate intake of 20 key bone nutrients||Excess alcohol consumption||Processed and synthetic foods|
|Undereating or food restriction||Colas and other sugar-sweetened drinks||Eating on the run|
|Excessive protein intake||Skipping and incomplete meals|
|Excess vitamin A|
Table 2. Lifestyle Factors
|Inadequate physical activity||Smoking|
|Poor muscle development||Significant weight loss|
|Sub-optimal strength||Use of recreational drugs|
|Immobilization (prolonged bedrest)||Use of medications (see Table 3 below)|
|Weightlessness (as occurs in space flight)||Birth control methods such as tubal ligation|
|Other surgeries such as hysterectomy, bariatric, gastrointestinal, etc.|
|Emotions such as worry, unhappiness, fear|
|Response to stress (increased levels of cortisol, epinephrine norepinephrine)|
Table 3. Medical Conditions
|Endocrine or Metabolic Causes||Connective Tissue/Genetic Disorders||Digestive Disorders / Dysfunction||Rheumatological & Autoimmune Diseases||Neurological Diseases|
|Acromegaly||Cystic fibrosis||Celiac disease||Ankylosing spondylitis||Epilepsy|
|Ehlers-Danlos syndrome||Chronic hepatic disease||Lupus||Parkinson’s disease|
(Types I and II)
|Glycogen storage diseases||Gastrectomy||Multiple sclerosis||Polio, history of|
|Gaucher’s disease||Hemophilia||Gastric bypass (Bariatric surgery) or other GI surgery||Rheumatoid arthritis||Spinal cord injury|
|Hemochromatosis||Homocystinuria||Inflammatory bowel disease||Bone, Bone Marrow, and Blood Diseases||Psychiatric Disorders|
|Hyperparathyroidism||Hypophosphatasia||Malabsorption syndrome (celiac disease and IBD, such as Crohn’s disease or ulcerative colitis)||Leukemia and lymphomas||Depression|
|Hyperthyroidism (Graves Disease)||Idiopathic hypercalciuria||Malnutrition||Mastocytosis||Anorexia nervosa and bulimia|
(sex hormone deficiency), including:
Androgen insensitivityAthletic amenorrheaEstrogen deficiencyHyperprolactinemia Klinefelter’s syndromePremature menopauseTurner’s syndrome
|Marfan syndrome||Pancreatic disease||Multiple myeloma||Other health factors|
|Hypopituitarism||Menkes steely hair syndrome||Primary biliary cirrhosis||Plasma cell dyscrasias||Alcoholism|
|Hyperpituitarism||Muscular dystrophy||Renal Diseases||Post-transplant bone disease||Amyloidosis|
|Thyrotoxicosis||Osteogenesis imperfecta||Chronic kidney disease||Sickle cell disease||Congestive heart failure|
|Pulmonary Diseases||Panhypopituitarism||End stage renal disease||Idiopathic scoliosis|
|Chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD)||Pseudoglioma||Renal tubular acidosis||Parental history of hip fracture|
|Emphysema||Porphyria||Premature ovarian failure|
|Riley-Day syndrome||Prior fracture as an adult|
*(Not all drugs in each category affect bone health, so be sure to ask your physician to consider one that is less harmful to bone.)
Aluminum-containing antacids: interfere with the intestinal absorption of calcium.
Anticoagulants (heparin): used to prevent blood clotting. Vitamin K is one of several vitamins that play a role in bone metabolism. Since some oral anticoagulants interfere with vitamin K, their long-term use may increase the risk of osteoporosis, particularly of the spine and ribs.
Anticonvulsants: interfere with vitamin D metabolism, thereby lowering the availability of calcium for bone mineralization. The two widely used anti-epileptic drugs phenytoin (Dilantin®) and carbamazepine (Tegretol®) are recognized to have direct effects on bone cells.
Anti-depressants: daily use of SSRIs (selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors), a popular anti-depressant, may lead to increased risk for fragility fracture in older adults. Daily use of SSRIs is associated with a reduction in bone density in the hip and spine and with an increased risk of falling. Examples of drugs in this class include Prozac®, Paxil® and Zoloft®.
Anti-neoplastics (cancer treatments): used to treat a variety of cancers, immune disorders and resistant arthritic conditions. Cancer treatment-induced bone loss (CTIBL) is most common in breast (including aromatase inhibitors) or prostate cancer patients undergoing therapies resulting in low levels of sex hormones.
Conception control agents: reports suggest that women who use Depo-Provera® (Depo-medroxyprogesterone) may lose significant bone mineral density, possibly because of the low estrogen that it induces.
Cyclosporine A and tacrolimus
Glucocorticoids (≥ 5 mg/d of prednisone or equivalent for ≥ 3 mo)
Gonadotropin-releasing hormone (GnRH) analogues: used in the long-term treatment of endometriosis and uterine fibroids. GnRH therapy decreases production of the hormone estrogen to the levels women have after menopause. GnRH analogues are used in the treatment of breast cancer in women to suppress estrogen levels, and in prostate cancer in men to suppress testosterone levels.
Heartburn and ulcer medication: proton pump inhibitors that reduce stomach acid production have been associated with an increased fracture risk, perhaps because calcium absorption from food is less efficient in the absence of stomach acid.
Immunosuppressives: used in organ transplants and for the treatment of some diseases of the immune system.
Thiazolidinediones (diabetes medication): a study found a higher risk of fractures among women who take the drug rosiglitazone (Avandia®), possibly because the drug increases the activity of the cells that absorb bone in the bone remodeling process. Also, clinical trials have shown that female patients treated with pioglitazone (ACTOS®) for type 2 diabetes mellitus were at an increased risk of fracture, particularly of the forearm, hand and wrist, and foot, ankle, fibula and tibia. No increased risk of fracture was identified in men.
Thyroid hormone therapy: sufficient levels of thyroid hormones are necessary for normal bone development; excessive amounts, however, can cause bone loss over time.
I’m Dr. Susan E Brown. I am a clinical nutritionist, medical anthropologist, writer and motivational speaker. Learn my time-tested 6 step natural approach to bone health in my online courses.
Leave a ReplyWant to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!