home » blog »

Tomatoes: Summer's unexpected bone builder

It’s tomato season! The brilliantly-colored summer treats common in all our gardens are major players in one of today’s leading-edge research topics in osteoporosis: how oxidative damage causes the inflammation which leads to bone breakdown.

What makes tomatoes so interesting to the scientists studying the effects of oxidative damage? Tomatoes are particularly highly in a bone-protective antioxidant known as lycopene. It has long been noted that people who consume more tomatoes, tomato paste, sauces, juice, and tomato products of all sorts experience a lower fracture rate than those who consume less.

Last year, Canadian researchers conducted an intervention study using various amounts of lycopene extracted from tomatoes. They found that consumption of 30 mg of lycopene a day significantly reduced both oxidative damage and bone breakdown. While smaller amounts of lycopene were not tested in this study, other population diet studies report that daily intakes of just 12.64 mg lycopene are related to significantly lowered fracture risk. When you reduce bone breakdown, bone is preserved and fracture incidence is reduced. These very positive effects make it worth it to spend time gardening.

So how can you get from 12 to 30 milligrams of lycopene a day without taking extra supplements? It's really quite easy if you like tomatoes as I do. Bright red tomatoes — in sauces, soup, juices, or just plain sliced up on the plate—are loaded with lycopene!

Tomato products and lycopene content

Tomato product               Serving Size          Lycopene content

Tomato paste                  1/4 cup                  18.84 mg

Tomato puree, canned      1 cup                     54.38 mg

Tomato sauce, canned      1 cup                     34.25 mg

Pasta sauce, canned         1 cup                    31.66 mg

Vegetable juice cocktail     1 cup                    23.38 mg

Tomato juice                   1 cup                    21.91 mg

Tomato soup                   1 cup                    13.05 mg

Tomato, raw                   1 whole                   3.17 mg

Oh, and if you don't like tomatoes, enjoy watermelon, papaya, grapefruit — also good sources of lycopene.


Finally, I already hear this question a lot, “But aren’t tomatoes are acid-forming?” True, tomatoes are slightly acid-forming, but their benefits outweigh any small acid contribution, which can be easily buffered with our Alkaline for Life Diet®. Be well and enjoy the fruits of summer! Here's a recipe to get you started:


Bone-healthy salsa recipe
•    4 large tomatoes (or 6 plum tomatoes) chopped
•    1 small white onion, diced
•    Juice from 1 lemon
•    Handful of fresh cilantro
•    Salt to taste
Mix together and serve (or add a chopped cucumber for a great summer tomato salad).


References:
Sahni, S et al., Protective Effect of Total Carotenoid and Lycopene Intake On The Risk Of Hip Fracture: A 17 Year, Follow-Up From the Framingham Osteoporosis Study, JBMR, Vol. 24, No.6.2009:10861094.
Mackinnon, ES et al., Supplementation with the Antioxidant Lycopene Significantly Decreases Oxidative Stress Parameters In The Bone Resorption Marker N-telopeptide  Of Type I Collagen In Postmenopausal Women.  Osteoporosis international (2011) 22:1091-1101
US Dept. of Agriculture, Agriculture Research Service. USDA National Nutrient Database For Standard Reference, Release 24, Lycopene.

 

We created the Better Bones blog as our forum to express opinions and educate the public about natural means of supporting and improving bone health and overall wellness. As part of this forum, we sometimes discuss medical issues and medications, and their effects on bone health in general. However, we cannot advise readers about specific medical issues in this forum. If you wish to obtain advice from Susan E. Brown, PhD, about your specific bone health and nutritional concerns, please visit our Consultations page. Other specific medical questions should be referred to your healthcare provider.

 

Comments

July 16. 2012 13:42

I heard cooking tomatoes gives the best amount of lycopene.
Your chart seems to show that also with raw tomatoes at 3.17 mg

Patrice

July 24. 2012 16:44

This publication about tomatoes surprises me a lot....I have been in a VG diet since 40 yrs and in the past, ate a lot of tomatoes together with a lot of plain unsweetened yogurts or cottage cheese. And 8 yrs ago, doctors detected that I have a very severe osteoporosis (-5/-4). They immediately asked me to stop eating any dairy products and raw veggies (since on the top of that I have digestive disorders). So all what I am reading about calcium in yogur,tomato lycopene etc....makes me laugh because for sure it didn't work for me unfortunately...

ODILE

August 7. 2012 09:51

Hi -- In the table, the decimal fractions of a mg are what scientists call "insignificant figures", ie, ones that repeated measurements would result in different values.  And the extra digits make the numbers hard to "digest".  So they can be suppressed not only without losing anything, but to advantage.  This is something to keep in mind in presenting any kind of numerical results.

The generalization is not that any digits past the decimal point are insignificant; rather it is that any digits likely to be essentially random upon repeated measurements carry no information and are best rounded off to whatever order of magnitude seems likely to be stable.

For Odile -- Your problem is likely a lack of vitamin K2.  See the discussion elsewhere on the site of the twenty-some nutrients that are necessary to healthy bones.

JBG

August 7. 2012 15:00

It is my understanding that in order to absorb the lycopene, fat is needed i.e. a little olive oil on those raw tomatoes.  That's why cooked tomatoes deliver more of their lycopene -- some kind of fat is often involved in these products.  My favorite summer recipe is pasta w/ raw tomato sauce.  For each serving:

1 large ripe tomato (skinned by dropping it in boiling water for 12
   seconds), cut up & marinated for 1/2 hour in:
1 Tbs. olive oil
1 clove chopped garlic
salt
sliced fresh basil leaves
optional: add chopped fresh mozzerella

Pour over cooked pasta...YUM!  The mozzerella melts over the hot posta & the tomatoes retain their delicious fresh taste.

phyllis herman

August 8. 2012 00:17

What about the lycopene content of tomato sauce that comes in a jar?  Is it the same as the canned tomato sauce?

Thank you.

Diane Zych

September 20. 2012 07:46

Hi Diane, jarred tomato sauce does contain lycopene in similar amounts to canned. Cooked tomatoes best for nutrient absorption, and as the chart shows, lycopene content is actually higher per serving.

Blog Admin

Add comment





Loading




Recent Posts